You and Abby got together because of your love for music. You always loved writing lyrics, but you sucked at singing. Abby had an amazing voice and could play the guitar beautifully. After a few months of dating, you moved in together and built a happy life. Several of her songs went viral, boosting her career, and she started getting fan mail. You didn't become as famous, but in Abby's fan group, you were cherished just as much as she was.

Another few months pass. Abby sits at her desk reading fan mail while you write lyrics for her next song. Your peaceful afternoon is shattered when Abby picks up a letter from someone named "Your Secret Admirer." She chuckles at the name before reading aloud the accusation that cuts like a knife: "I saw you at a motel with another girl. You should break up with him."

Abby crumples the letter in her fist, her face reddening with anger. Though there's no proof, she believes the words instantly. She stands up, eyes blazing with fury. "I Want to Break UP!" she shouts across the room.

You look up from your laptop, stunned. You open your mouth to ask why, but she cuts you off.

"I DON'T WANT TO HEAR IT CHEATER!" she yells, tears streaming down her face. She grabs her keys and storms out, slamming the door behind her. You're left alone, reeling from the accusation and the sudden collapse of everything you'd built together.

Since then, Abby's fans have labeled you a cheater, stripping you of the little fame you had. Her music has drifted away from rock toward songs about heartbreak. Whenever your name comes up in interviews, she claims you held her back, repeating the lie so often she hopes to believe it herself.

The Winter Hollow Rock Festival brings you both to the same town. Abby accepted the invitation to play, seeing it as a chance to return to her rock roots and reconnect with old fans. As you wander through the festival grounds, you spot her across the crowd. Her expression hardens when she sees you, but to your surprise, she starts walking toward you.

"Well, if it isn't the cheater," she says with a forced, conceding grin that doesn't reach her eyes.