Nights were always the most calmin’ for Lottie, even though Devil’s Springs never seemed to sleep.

Sure, there was always a light on somewhere in the city, some street lamp burnin’ the midnight oil or a candle in somebody’s window lightin’ the way, but ‘round the grounds of the Church of the Holy Blessed Virgin it was always a bit quieter. Somethin’ ‘bout hallowed ground always made people a little uneasy when it came to makin’ noise or lingerin’ ‘round it. All the better for her though considerin’ the company she was due t’have over.

Not that Father Charles exactly disapproved of what she did considerin’ the dirt she had on ‘im — they both knew Lottie heard what he got up to in that office o’ his and she’d cleaned enough of his cassocks to know that the water ain’t run red for some innocent little thing. Still, she ain’t breathed a word of it to him that she knew and definitely ain’t said a thing to the law; she was content to keep livin’ in a state of harmony since they both wanted to play dumb to the big, murderous elephant in the room.

Besides, it weren’t like Lottie was all that blameless either. The nuns had told she’d been born under a Blood Moon, a most wicked omen for the most vile of women if there ever was one, and she had most definitely exceeded those expectations. She’d grown into somethin’ godless and wicked, a woman with a black heart and a damned soul, and all it did was make her smile.

Sometimes Lottie still could feel Sister Beatrice’s hands on her body, hear her shrill voice screamin’ and ringin’ in her ears. She had prayed and prayed for what felt like days and nights, beggin’ for the Heavenly Father to give her some release from the Hell she’d come to know as home — or even for Sister Beatrice to somehow be struck dead — only for it to fall on deaf ears. And what almighty n’ lovin’ God would abandon His most vulnerable and in need? What Lord could hear the cries of children and turn His attention elsewhere?

Certainly not one that Lottie wanted to follow. How a God could ignore His faithful was beyond her understandin’, not that she ever wanted to get how anyone could ever let such sufferin’ happen.

...and there was that sticky little nature o’ her, ah, proclivities as it were. How her heart seemed t’beat quicker’n a damn hare’s as she walked through the more unsavory districts of Devil’s Springs and caught sight of a whore leanin’ over a balcony, wavin’ a handkerchief her way. She was never one to deny herself indulgences, ‘specially after she found gods that actually listened to her and had no qualms ‘bout her livin’ for more’n blind worship, but she knew she couldn’t be so... brazen with how she was.

Those feelings only got worse where you were concerned. Lottie’d first met you ‘cause of Father Charles considerin’ that damnable man had takin’ to killin’ off the parishioners who he thought were beyond savin’. First he had Lupe doin’ his dirty work for ‘im, thinkin’ he was slick since he weren’t the one pullin’ the trigger, but she knew where the church money was bein’ funneled to. Lupe’d told Lottie herself ‘bout the ordeal — a priest usin’ tithin’ money to kill the very folk givin’ to ‘em... sickenin’ and evil things, worse than any witch’d do.

But then Charles got suspicious after seein’ the two hang ‘round one another, ‘cause gods forbid women speak t’one another unsupervised, and asked whoever Lupe worked for to send another woman instead. Whoever was in charge sent you, someone who went n’ took Lottie’s breath away more’n Lupe ever had. She still remembered the day you first met in the nave, how you looked like a damn near angel bathed in light filterin’ in from the stained glass windows. You’d said a quick hello before Father Charles swooped in, takin’ you with him, but you’d looked over your shoulder for one last lingerin’ look before disappearing into his office.

Lottie’d been hooked from then on, seekin’ you out whenever you were on church grounds. You’d shared tea together, had good conversations in the vestibule, even walked the small garden she tended to, and durin’ those times shared more’n a few lingerin’ little touches and coy lil’ looks. Interest, clear as day, but frustratingly never acted on by either of you.

Tonight, though, Lottie vowed to have somethin’ change. You’d sent a letter in advance, lettin’ her know you’d be comin’ back to the church grounds with the final list of ingredients she asked for. This whole time, you’d been unwittingly gatherin’ ingredients that’d help Lottie do something rather untoward with you, things no good-hearted and decent woman should be doin’. But she weren’t no saint, Lord knows she was a damned sinner; the Bible made it rather clear where it stood on folks like her, said they were abominations t’be driven out, as if there weren’t a wolf in sheep’s clothes leadin’ the flock towards certain doom.

Lottie watched idly as the kettle on the rectory’s stove slowly heated, the crackle of the firewood heatin’ it muffled by the heavy iron door containin’ the flame. There weren’t not a single shred of guilt in her as she prepared the tea mixture, the very ones Edith told her of way back when. Somethin’ bout ‘em aphrodisiac, with that magick enhanced by whatever else she added, but it had t’be carefully measured lest she have a body on her hands. Lottie wanted to have you in her bed and heart, not in an unmarked grave out in the Bayou Lonbraj.

She startled when she heard the door to the rectory open, whippin’ ‘round and half expecting Father Charles to be there to cuss her out, but it was only you. Lottie’d been so damn focused on makin’ sure she ain’t accidentally kill you with the tea she’d offer she hadn’t even heard you come in, let alone the shrill whistle of the kettle. She was quick to pull it off the burner, heart hammerin’ in her chest despite the way she looked as cool as could be on the outside. Couldn’t let her favorite lil’ outlaw get suspicious of her, could she?

“! Ain’t you a sight for sore eyes,” Lottie said softly, the plush curve of her lips spreadin’ into an easy smile. She didn’t have to fake bein’ happy ‘round you, never in a million damn years. “C’mon in, I reckon y’must be tired from all that runnin’ ‘round I made you do, sugar. You best get comfortable and rest those legs o’ yours, and you know I ain’t gonna take no for an answer.”

Lottie was quick to make her way to your side and get the rectory’s door shut behind you lest any nosy passerby see a questionable woman visitin’ the church grounds. She gestured to the little wooden table, already set with two delicate porcelain cups atop chipped saucers with a pot of sugar ‘tween ‘em, nothin’ too fancy but it’d do for what she had in mind. Just a few sips and she’d be able to help you back to her room, strip those road leathers off and see what lay under...

She brought that ol’ and chipped teapot of hers to where you sat at the table, not even stumblin’ for a second as she poured you both a steamin’ cup, eager to have you sip and slowly succumb to the potent herbs she’d mixed together. Lottie sat across from you, resting her chin on her hand as she carefully spooned some sugar in her tea.

“I’ve been meanin’ t’thank you for all you’ve done for me,” she murmured. “Figured some tea is the least I can do while we catch up. So, go on, take a sip and tell me all I missed with ya.”